| Date | Figures | Name | Opposition | Venue | ||||
| 1 | 30 May 1992 | 8 | - | 10 | D | Fraser | vs West Tanfield 2nd XI | Away |
| 2 | 5 June 1976 | 8 | - | 10 | R | Pickles | vs Hampsthwaite 2nd XI | Away |
| 3 | 3 July 1976 | 8 | - | 12 | R | Pickles | vs Newby Hall 2nd XI | Away |
| 4 | 15 July 1967 | 8 | - | 22 | R | Pickles | vs Rainton | Home |
| 5 | 12 July 1980 | 8 | - | 27 | J | Montgomery | vs Hampsthwaite 2nd XI | Home |
| 6 | 29 July 1989 | 8 | - | 28 | S | Fryer | vs West Tanfield 2nd XI | Home |
| 7 | 12 August 2000 | 8 | - | 54 | D | Fraser | vs Ripley | Home |
| 8 | 5 August 1995 | 8 | - | 66 | S | Blackburn | vs Burnt Yates | Away |
| 9 | 15 July 1972 | 7 | - | 9 | P | Kirk | vs Wath | Home |
| 10 | 23 June 1984 | 7 | - | 14 | D | Fraser | vs Harrogate Amateurs | Away |
| 11 | 13 May 1972 | 7 | - | 14 | R | Pickles | vs Rainton | Home |
| 12 | 1 June 1991 | 7 | - | 15 | P | Raistrick | vs Dacre Banks 2nd XI | Home |
| 13 | 25 April 1992 | 7 | - | 20 | K | Bain | vs Killinghall 2nd XI | Home |
| 14 | 9 September 1989 | 7 | - | 23 | P | Raistrick | vs Burton Leonard 2nd XI | Home |
| 15 | 17 September 1983 | 7 | - | 25 | R | Pickles | vs Ouseburn | Home |
| 16 | 29 August 1964 | 7 | - | 25 | K | Gamble | vs Thirsk Junction | Home |
| 17 | 5 July 1980 | 7 | - | 27 | J | Montgomery | vs Killinghall 2nd XI | Away |
| 18 | 23 June 1973 | 7 | - | 32 | A | Atkinson | vs Baldersby | Home |
| 19 | 19 June 1999 | 7 | - | 35 | D | Fraser | vs Blubberhouses | Home |
| 20 | 1 September 1979 | 7 | - | 35 | P | Edmonds | vs Pannal 2nd XI | Away |
| 21 | 21 July 1979 | 7 | - | 35 | J | Montgomery | vs Helperby | Home |
| 22 | 7 July 1990 | 7 | - | 40 | P | Raistrick | vs Knaresborough Forest 2 | Home |
| 23 | 14 August 1999 | 7 | - | 43 | P | Goldsmith | vs Bishop Monkton | Home |
| 24 | 1 August 1981 | 7 | - | 44 | K | Bain | vs Staveley 2nd XI | Home |
| 25 | 1 September 1990 | 7 | - | 46 | S | Blackburn | vs Dacre Banks 2nd XI | Away |
| 26 | 29 May 1982 | 7 | - | 46 | K | Bain | vs Pannal 2nd XI | Away |
| 27 | 12 July 1997 | 7 | - | 47 | S | Blackburn | vs Wath | Away |
| 28 | 8 July 1995 | 7 | - | 58 | S | Blackburn | vs North Stainley | Away |
| 29 | 22 August 1964 | 6 | - | 10 | K | Gamble | vs Thornton-le-moor | Away |
| 30 | 21 May 1994 | 6 | - | 13 | D | Fraser | vs Goldsborough | Home |
| 31 | 31 May 1986 | 6 | - | 13 | K | Bain | vs St Georges | Away |
| 32 | 24 May 1975 | 6 | - | 14 | G | Edmonds | vs Sowerby | Home |
| 33 | 18 September 1993 | 6 | - | 15 | S | Blackburn | vs North Stainley | Home |
| 34 | 27 May 1995 | 6 | - | 16 | K | Bain | vs Burnt Yates | Home |
| 35 | 15 July 2000 | 6 | - | 16 | M | Fettes | vs Lofthouse & Middlesmoor | Home |
| 36 | 21 May 1977 | 6 | - | 16 | M | Blackburn | vs Ripon 2nd XI | Home |
| 37 | 8 May 1976 | 6 | - | 16 | R | Pickles | vs Darley 2nd XI | Home |
| 38 | 5 August 2006 | 6 | - | 18 | D | Fraser | vs Masham | Away |
| 39 | 17 May 1980 | 6 | - | 19 | H | Pickard | vs Burton Leonard 2nd XI | Away |
| 40 | 8 July 1967 | 6 | - | 19 | R | Pickles | vs Sharow | Away |
| 41 | 15 August 1992 | 6 | - | 20 | C | Harford-Cross | vs West Tanfield 2nd XI | Home |
| 42 | 2 August 1980 | 6 | - | 20 | J | Montgomery | vs Glasshouses 2nd XI | Away |
| 43 | 29 July 2000 | 6 | - | 21 | P | Goldsmith | vs Staveley | Home |
| 44 | 21 July 2001 | 6 | - | 21 | M | Fettes | vs Galphay & Winksley | Away |
| 45 | 17 August 2002 | 6 | - | 22 | R | Hooks | vs Lofthouse C.C | Away |
| 46 | 22 May 1976 | 6 | - | 23 | R | Pickles | vs ICI 2nd XI | Home |
| 47 | 28 April 1973 | 6 | - | 23 | D | Starmer | vs Leeming | |
| 48 | 12 July 1975 | 6 | - | 24 | A | Sturdy | vs Well | Away |
| 49 | 7 September 1991 | 6 | - | 25 | P | Raistrick | vs Ripon 2nd XI | Home |
| 50 | 21 June 1969 | 6 | - | 25 | R | Pickles | vs Galphay & Winksley | Home |
| 51 | 3 June 1972 | 6 | - | 25 | A | Atkinson | vs Sharow | Home |
| 52 | 1 August 1964 | 6 | - | 26 | A | Atkinson | vs Wath | Home |
| 53 | 25 August 1973 | 6 | - | 28 | A | Atkinson | vs Sowerby | Away |
| 54 | 28 April 1984 | 6 | - | 29 | K | Bain | vs Scotton | Home |
| 55 | 4 August 1973 | 6 | - | 29 | R | Pickles | vs Dishforth | Away |
| 56 | 27 June 1964 | 6 | - | 31 | A | Atkinson | vs Thirsk Junction | Away |
| 57 | 11 August 1973 | 6 | - | 31 | A | Atkinson | vs Rainton | Away |
| 58 | 16 July 1977 | 6 | - | 32 | A | Atkinson | vs Pateley Bridge 2nd XI | Home |
| 59 | 12 July 1969 | 6 | - | 32 | A | Atkinson | vs Well | Home |
| 60 | 23 August 1997 | 6 | - | 33 | D | Fraser | vs Birstwith | Away |
| 61 | 18 July 1981 | 6 | - | 34 | K | Bain | vs Harrogate Amateurs | Away |
| 62 | 6 August 1983 | 6 | - | 34 | K | Bain | vs Markington | Away |
| 63 | 10 June 1967 | 6 | - | 34 | R | Pickles | vs Well | Home |
| 64 | 23 May 1964 | 6 | - | 34 | R | Pickles | vs Wath | Away |
| 65 | 17 July 1971 | 6 | - | 34 | R | Pickles | vs Baldersby | Away |
| 66 | 23 June 1979 | 6 | - | 35 | R | Peacock | vs Pannal 2nd XI | Home |
| 67 | 22 May 1982 | 6 | - | 36 | K | Bain | vs Goldsborough | Home |
| 68 | 13 June 1992 | 6 | - | 38 | S | Buckton | vs Staveley 2nd XI | Home |
| 69 | 7 September 1997 | 6 | - | 40 | D | Fraser | vs Harrogate Strays | Home |
| 70 | 17 August 1985 | 6 | - | 40 | D | Fraser | vs West Tanfield 2nd XI | Away |
| 71 | 14 July 1984 | 6 | - | 43 | P | Edmonds | vs Scotton | Away |
| 72 | 27 April 1985 | 6 | - | 44 | A | Lofthouse | vs Harrogate Amateurs | Home |
| 73 | 31 May 1975 | 6 | - | 44 | A | Atkinson | vs Wath | Home |
| 74 | 24 August 1985 | 6 | - | 45 | K | Bain | vs Scotton | Away |
| 75 | 17 June 1989 | 6 | - | 46 | D | Fraser | vs Hampsthwaite | Away |
| 76 | 10 August 1996 | 6 | - | 46 | S | Blackburn | vs Markington | Away |
| 77 | 11 August 1990 | 6 | - | 47 | S | Fryer | vs Pateley Bridge 2nd XI | Away |
| 78 | 2 September 1989 | 6 | - | 48 | D | Fraser | vs Staveley | Away |
| 79 | 11 July 1964 | 6 | - | 50 | A | Atkinson | vs Kirklington | Home |
| 80 | 27 April 1996 | 6 | - | 51 | S | Blackburn | vs Ripon 2nd XI | Away |
| 81 | 17 May 1997 | 6 | - | 51 | D | Fraser | vs Knaresborough Forest | Home |
| 82 | 20 August 1983 | 6 | - | 62 | K | Bain | vs Burnt Yates | Home |
| 83 | 30 June 1984 | 6 | - | 71 | K | Bain | vs Killinghall 2nd XI | Away |
| 84 | 8 July 2000 | 6 | - | 81 | P | Goldsmith | vs Burton Leonard | Away |